Barefoot running – Is it better? Part 1

by | Mar 18, 2015

Part 1

You may have heard the claim that barefoot running is more natural as it promotes a front-foot strike (FFS) pattern. The idea is that shoes are a modern invention that interfere with the normal foot-strike pattern and mechanics.

Is it true?

With respect to the research that is out there, the jury is still out on the positives and negatives of barefoot or minimalist running. The systematic reviews1 that have looked at barefoot runnings only find research that is of low to moderate quality. The moderate quality evidence does suggest differences such as less maximum ground reaction forces, less foot/ankle dorsiflexion at contact, less ground contact time, shorter stride length, increased stride frequency, increased knee flexion at contact when barefoot running. However, there is no evidence that clearly says these differences make barefoot running better or worse. There may be some conditions/circumstances where barefoot running may be helpful but research has not yet made them known. However, the well-respected exercise physiologist and runner Dr. Peter Larson suggests that there may never be an answer and we should use the footwear that feels comfortable/works for us.

Should I try it?

Barefoot PictureI think that it is certainly possible to consider barefoot running if done cautiously and progressively, but there are still many unknowns. We do, however, know more about foot strike, and this may be something more appropriate for you to adjust in certain known circumstances.

FFS is not necessarily more natural. Research shows that the majority, ~90%, of runners use a rear-foot strike (RFS) pattern2-3. A not dissimilar number, ~70%, was seen when a habitually barefoot Kenyan tribe was studied4.

If this is the case, what has pushed people to recommend FFS and barefoot running? One reason may be a highly-publicized study of elite athletes that found RFS running to have twice the injury rate of FFS running5. But this study had two major limitations: it was of a very small sample group – only 52 athletes, and they were elite track athletes. This means that we have to consider the results with caution when giving advice to the much larger and diverse populations of recreational, youth, and even competitive runners. Other studies that have been more representative of the general population do not show any difference in injury risk or performance between foot-strike.

If your normal running pattern is comfortable for you, why change it?! Stay tuned for Part 2…

Reference List

1. Perkins KP, Hanney WJ, Rothschild CE. The risks and benefits of running barefoot or in minimalist shoes: a systematic review. Sports Health. 2014;6(6):475-80.

2. Larson P, Higgins E, Kaminski J, et al. Foot strike patterns of recreational and sub-elite runners in a long-distance road race. J Sports Sci. 2011;29(15):1665-73.

3. De almeida MO, Saragiotto BT, Yamato TP, Lopes AD. Is the rearfoot pattern the most frequently foot strike pattern among recreational shod distance runners?. Phys Ther Sport. 2015;16(1):29-33.

4. Hatala KG, Dingwall HL, Wunderlich RE, Richmond BG. Variation in foot strike patterns during running among habitually barefoot populations. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(1):e52548.

5. Daoud AI, Geissler GJ, Wang F, Saretsky J, Daoud YA, Lieberman DE. Foot strike and injury rates in endurance runners: a retrospective study. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2012;44(7):1325-34.

No all stress fractures need an expensive boot

Boots For Stress Fractures and What Exercises Help The Most?

Table of Contents Have you noticed how many people are given a boot to treat stress fractures? If you’ve had ...
Read More

Blood Flow Restriction Training

Table of Contents Why should we lift? Living an active life requires certain levels of strength. For example, when we ...
Read More
Tendon Compression an important thing to consider for some tendons

Tendon Compression – Important to Consider For Some Tendons!

Not all tendons and tendon pain should be treated the same. For example, we tend to consider Achilles tendon pain ...
Read More

What Is The Right Running Shoe For Me?!

Modern advances (and claims) have not done much for injury risk! Runners assign a huge level of importance to footwear ...
Read More
Carpal tunnel and neck pain care in huntsville and madison alabama

When is Carpal Tunnel Not Carpal Tunnel

There is often the assumption that numbness in the hand is due to carpal tunnel syndrome. However, oftentimes these symptoms ...
Read More
Huntsville Madison runners need strong soleus muscles to help avoid achilles problems

Why You Need a Strong Soleus!

Why You Need a Strong Soleus! The soleus is a big calf muscle, but oftentimes is unloved! It is actually ...
Read More
Loading...

0 Comments

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Barefoot Running - Part 2 - […] Last post we saw that research has not proven barefoot running to be better in general than running with…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

google logoPhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.PhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.
5 Stars - Based on 48 User Reviews

facebook logoPhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.PhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.
5 Stars - Based on 22 User Reviews

Never miss a blog!

Andrew is by far the most effective Physical Therapist specializing in helping in athletes increase performance, endurance, and techniques to reduce injury. The sessions he offers are tailored to the athlete and utilize scientifically based research. I appreciate all he has done to provide me guidance and direction in addressing several recurring issues!

Barry Kirkland Avatar Barry Kirkland
5/15/2019

Andrew was recommended to me by several members of the Huntsville running community when I experienced pain in my right heel this winter that severely impacted my running. Andrew examined my running style and leg strength and gave me a series of exercises that quickly helped reduce the pain and build back up my running. Andrew has a great knowledge of the latest research and targeted solutions for individual runners. Now I am running pain free and feel I have a better foundation for long term running fitness.

David Chadwick Avatar David Chadwick
6/16/2019

Andrew is super great! He keeps up with the latest research and uses it to better treat his patients. I came to him because I was having knee pain that kept me from running like I wanted to. He did a running analysis and identified some problem points. With the exercises her prescribed, I was able to get back to running (and was stronger), and I even completed a half marathon only a couple months after starting PT. Unlike traditional PT, I only had to go a few times over a couple months as opposed to several times per week,... read more

Melissa Wilk Avatar Melissa Wilk
4/09/2019

- Want to be treated without surgery or medication? -

Claim your FREE consultation with the PT who has the most

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Google reviews in Huntsville Alabama!