Anterior Cruciate Ligament injury prevention – Part 2

by | May 15, 2015

Last postwe discussed the anatomy and mechanics of the ACL, as well as what predisposes it to tears. This post is going to consider the more important, practical, part: how do we reduce ACL injury risk?

What can we do to reduce risk?

  • Basic exercises:
    • We can most certainly work on improving strength or flexibility deficits that we see in a thorough physical examination. These are easy things to work on – a no-brainer! We even have research to help us decide on the best exercises for these issues. However, basic exercises alone are not enough.

  • Neuromuscular control:
    • We need strength and flexibility, but the application of these is even more important. Recent research has focused on the neuromuscular control of the lower extremity. In other words, how are the joints controlled and kept in optimal positions when they are under load and stress? The key word here is “neuro”, in that there is a component of injury risk reduction which is reliant on the brain or is learned. A recent systematic review1 out of Australia found that the available data suggests that 26% of non-contact injuries could be prevented with neuromuscular programs. Although there are not yet enough studies with enough participants to make this finding statistically significant, it does suggest that the most useful application of neuromuscular programs would be in high-risk sports such as soccer.

So, what is an example of a neuromuscular program?

A good example of an injury prevention program that employs a high level of neuromuscular exercises is one developed for soccer: the FIFA 11 plus:

Fifa 11 plus manual

 (Check out the sidebar (desktop) or below the article (mobile) for other Fifa 11 links)

This training program focuses on dynamic drills and exercises that not only build strength, but require neurological engagement. For example, rather than just doing static leg raises or planks, it calls for lateral jumping drills or single-leg squats. A recent systematic review2 found that this program does improve neuromuscular control and significantly reduce the number of injuries in male and female amateur soccer players. While not specifically focused on ACL injury prevention, the overall effect of increasing strength and neuromuscular control will be expected to reduce ACL injuries. The program is generic so that it can be applied to a whole team, but as our previous post showed, some people are at greater injury risk than others, so a neuromuscular program may be even more important for this high-risk population.

Is there a way to screen people for injury risk/poor neuromuscular control?

The Landing Error Scoring System (LESS) is a tool for identifying high-risk movement patterns. The tool has good measurement reliability and has recently been shown3 to be effective in predicting ACL injury in soccer players. With this measure, the athlete stands on top of a 30cm box, placed half their height from the landing area. They jump forward to the landing area and immediately jump for maximal height straight upwards. The task is recorded on video from the front and the side. The video is then replayed and scored against the LESS. A higher LESS score indicates a greater number of landing errors and therefore a poorer technique. This way, the high-risk individuals in a team or group of players can be identified. While all athletes can benefit from a neuromuscular program, those in the higher risk category may benefit from closer follow-up and re-testing. The study suggests a score of 6 or higher as being high risk in soccer players. The videos below show the test in action and the footage we collect:

In this example we identified three small faults:

Knee flexion on landing is an element of the Landing Error Scoring System

Knee flexion

Foot rotationon landing is looked at using the Landing Error Scoring System (LESS)

Foot Rotation

Knees dropping inward of the foot is a predictor of risk for ACL tear

Knee:foot position

  • Not enough knee flexion on initial landing
  • Too much rotation at the foot
  • Knees falling inside of the medial foot

These faults thankfully only put her in the low risk category! Even so, we can work to reduce her injury risk further by correcting these small faults. In this patients’ particular case, the faults seen correlate with physical findings of over-pronation, which can be corrected with appropriate footwear. The knees falling inside of the medial foot is a very common finding in young female athletes, and can also be caused by weak gluteal muscles. This underscores the need for a thorough physical exam in coordination with the video analysis – the video alone showing the knees falling is not enough to determine the underlying cause of the fault.

Understanding the anatomy and mechanics that leads to injury is important. A Physical Therapist has the training to do this. However, keeping up with the growing evidence base is equally important. That is why PhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc has focused on the sporting population, particularly with respect to injury prevention. We are devoted to staying up-to-date with the latest sports-science research. We have also invested in professional-grade equipment to perform LESS in the clinic or on the field. We hope to be able to work with local soccer clubs, teams, individual players, and parents to introduce this to our local community. By doing this, I hope that we can reduce our athletes’ risk, so that we will not have to conduct as much rehab on surgically-reconstructed ligaments! Following this link to the page about our ACL injury prevention screening service.

Reference List:

1) Hespanhol junior LC, Kamper SJ. Prevention of non-contact anterior cruciate ligament injuries: PEDro synthesis. Br J Sports Med. 2015;49(2):133-4.

2) Barengo NC, Meneses-echávez JF, Ramírez-vélez R, Cohen DD, Tovar G, Bautista JE. The impact of the FIFA 11+ training program on injury prevention in football players: a systematic review. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2014;11(11):11986-2000.

3) Padua DA, Distefano LJ, Beutler AI, De la motte SJ, Distefano MJ, Marshall SW. The Landing Error Scoring System as a Screening Tool for an Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury-Prevention Program in Elite-Youth Soccer Athletes. J Athl Train. 2015;

What Is The Right Running Shoe For Me?!

Modern advances (and claims) have not done much for injury risk! Runners assign a huge level of importance to footwear ...
Read More
Carpal tunnel and neck pain care in huntsville and madison alabama

When is Carpal Tunnel Not Carpal Tunnel

There is often the assumption that numbness in the hand is due to carpal tunnel syndrome. However, oftentimes these symptoms ...
Read More
Huntsville Madison runners need strong soleus muscles to help avoid achilles problems

Why You Need a Strong Soleus!

Why You Need a Strong Soleus! The soleus is a big calf muscle, but oftentimes is unloved! It is actually ...
Read More
interview with a fitness professional in Huntsville and Madison with Joe Martin of Huntsville Adventure Boot Camp

Interview With Joe Martin of Huntsville Adventure Boot Camp

The Huntsville/Madison Health and Fitness Professionals I Trust #2 As a physical therapist it is often important to refer my ...
Read More
Evidence based treatment huntsville and madison alabama

Trick or Treat!

Trick or Treat - Is The Treatment To Good To Be True? When healthcare professionals recommend a treatment, it should ...
Read More
Ankle sprains live at physioworks in huntsville alabama providing top ankle physical therapy

What we do if Ankle Sprains Are Slowing us Down!

If you read our recent blog on ankle sprains (link here) you might be wondering what to do practically. This ...
Read More
Loading...

0 Comments

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Interview with Z-Flo, Inc. - PhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, inc - […] risk. We have discussed this somewhat with our two part ACL injury prevention series (Part 1, Part 2). Professional-grade…
  2. Anterior Cruciate Ligament injury prevention - Part 1 - […] Stay tuned for part 2, where we discuss the evidence about reducing these injuries, and how I apply this evidence…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

google logoPhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.PhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.
5 Stars - Based on 38 User Reviews

facebook logoPhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.PhysioWorks, Sports and Wellness, Inc.
5 Stars - Based on 19 User Reviews

Never miss a blog!

After limping my way through a 100km trail race and finally giving in to my bilateral Achilles tendinopathy, I went to Andrew for help. His well researched approach to therapy helped me progress from barely walking to increasing my running mileage so that I could make it to the start line of my goal 100mi race a little over 3 months later. Andrew's passion for sports therapy is obvious. His methods are based on the latest research in Orthopedics. You won't find a better PT in the area.

Luke Hough Avatar Luke Hough
1/30/2019

I had a knee injury that was about 2 years old by the time I saw Andrew. A combination of hoping it would get better on it's own and just not taking the time to get something done about (it was more annoying rather than debilitating) resulted in me putting off addressing it.

I was impressed with Andrew's assessment skills and his ability to explain the different compensations I had developed as a result of my injured knee. The exercises were challenging but doable and I really appreciated the videos he supplied so that I could check my form. He... read more

Tameron Harvell Avatar Tameron Harvell
4/13/2018

Over the years I've received treatment from 8 different centers in the Huntsville/Madison area for running-related injuries. While other centers were helpful in pain management, PhysioWorks was BY FAR the most helpful in finding the real cause of the problem. They laid out a plan for me to get right. Pretty great stuff.

Brandon Mader Avatar Brandon Mader
2/06/2019